Choose a budget everyone can meet
The best budget is one nobody feels they have to stretch for. Ask the group, or pick the lower number if opinions differ. State it as a single amount or a range, say whether tax and shipping count, and say what happens if a gift costs a little more.
Under about $10: small and thoughtful
At the lowest tier, personal beats expensive. Think of a good pen, a small plant, a favorite candy, a notebook, a tea bag sampler, or a handwritten card with a short memory. Handmade items such as baked goods work too if you know about allergies.
Around $20: useful things people enjoy
A mid-low budget fits a nice mug with cocoa, a paperback in a genre they like, a phone stand, a puzzle, socks, a candle, or a small local-shop find. A theme can help: coffee lover, gardener, cook, reader.
Around $30 to $50: a single better item
Here, one good item usually beats several small ones. Ideas include a quality insulated bottle, a board game for the family, a cozy blanket, a set of cooking tools, or a gift card to a place the person already likes. Check the wish list first, then buy within it.
How to pick without guessing
Use a questionnaire to learn favorites, allergies, and things to avoid. If you still cannot decide, choose something consumable, such as food or a hot drink, or an experience, such as a movie night kit. Avoid joke gifts that could embarrass the receiver in front of others, and skip anything that needs a size unless you know it.
Have a correction or a suggestion? Tell the studio.